The Weekly Bender: Navigating the Tight End Position

Sat Jul 5 11:27am ET
By HOWARD BENDER
Fantasy Writer

Related photo caption below

Bowers has high price tag


When I was an aspiring fantasy analyst so many years ago, there were two pieces of advice given to me that I have tried to pass down over the years in the hopes of mentoring and boosting others in their careers. The first was to have a second sport. Believe it or not, I began my career as a fantasy baseball guy but immediately adopted football as my second sport. Being able to cover both helped showcase both my abilities and dedication with around-the-clock work while also proving my worth as a full-time contributor.

The second piece of advice was to find a niche where no one seemed focused. I picked two. One was mock drafts. I began something called the Mock Draft Army where I filled half the draft room with fantasy industry greats and the other half with readers, subscribers, listeners, anyone who wanted to mock side-by-side with the experts whose content they were consuming. But the second niche I found was in the world of tight ends.

Most people assume I received the “Tight End Whisperer” moniker during a 2017 run when I picked a DFS bargain tight end to score a touchdown for 15 of the 16 weeks of the regular season. Maybe that’s when it went a little more mainstream, but in fact, I was breaking down the tight end position long before anyone gave it a thought. For years, all I saw was how it was a throwaway position but I knew there was more. I knew there was a way to gain an edge over the competition and if no one was looking at tight ends, I was going to find a way to use them to my and my readers' advantage. I was dishing out names like Rob Gronkowski, Jimmy Graham and Antonio Gates before they blew up and I dazzled people with late-round gems like Visanthe Shiancoe and Julius Thomas.

Today, there are a lot more eyeballs on the position. People either understand how to use it better to their advantage in the fantasy game or they understand that everyone and their grandma wants to be a fantasy football analyst, so they need a specialty. Even my co-host on the Fantasy Alarm Show, Andrew Cooper, has found a home breaking down tight ends. But this isn’t supposed to be a history of fantasy analysts. It’s the beginning of your training; your guide to drafting properly and getting the full value out of a position most don’t understand how to draft.

We don’t need to go all the way back to 2005 to start. We can simply pick up from where we left off last season, which was supposed to be the Year of the Tight End. It wasn’t and it left people incredibly frustrated.

We saw some incredible performances in 2023, including a group of rookies who helped us buck the trend of not drafting first-year tight ends. We watched Kyle Pitts have a 1,000-yard season in 2021, Trey McBride burst onto the scene in 2022 and in 2023, Sam LaPorta and Dalton Kincaid emerged as the next wave of elite-level tight ends. Add in Travis Kelce, George Kittle and Mark Andrews and suddenly this position was flush with talent with all sorts of draft possibilities.

Last season I recommended drafting one of the top-five tight ends – Kelce, LaPorta, McBride, Kincaid and Andrews. I had Kittle as a close sixth. A full season from one of them would give you a significant advantage over someone who waited on the position and drafted someone like Dallas Goedert or Tucker Kraft. Did it work? Sort of.

First off, I warned you against drafting LaPorta in the second round. He was still the third target in the Lions’ pecking order and he needed to surpass his 889-yard, 10-touchdown season to provide value where he was being drafted. That was a win for me, though he did finish the season with the sixth-most fantasy points. Of course, I also told you to wait until the fifth round where you could just grab McBride or Kincaid which only had a 50-percent success rate.

By the end of the season, in full-point PPR formats, only McBride and Kelce finished in the top five. They were joined by Kittle, but with LaPorta sixth and Andrews ninth, people were disillusioned. It didn’t matter that the difference between TE1 and TE10 was 99.4 points (5.4 points per game) and that there still was an advantage to drafting one of the top guys, but everyone was so focused on the misery of Kincaid and Pitts owners and the emergence of Brock Bowers followed by the rise of Jonnu Smith, that the anti-TE community continued to say drafting one early was a mistake. Was it? No. Did every top guy work out? Also, no, but it’s not enough of a reason to dismiss the position.

Entering this year, it would appear that we are destined to repeat our mistakes. People are drafting Bowers in the late-first or early second round, completely ignoring what happened with LaPorta last year or the fact that it’s a new coach, a new offense and a new quarterback. I’m not saying he’s going to be a complete bust a la Kincaid, but for where he is being drafted, he needs to duplicate last season’s totals.

As for the rest of this year’s top five, McBride and Kittle both have my full confidence. They maintain strong target shares within their offenses and while it may cost you a fourth or fifth-round pick, they should be worth it. The next two, LaPorta and T.J. Hockenson, are fine to draft, but given both are sitting third in their team’s target list, it might be better to bypass them as well.

In fact, take a look at the current fantasy football ADP. I’m not sure drafting anyone in the top-five is really going to be worth it. Do you really think it’s better to draft Bowers than someone like Josh Jacobs or A.J. Brown? McBride versus Kyren Williams? Kittle versus Garrett Wilson or Kenneth Walker? LaPorta versus RJ Harvey? I’ve outlined the point differentials at the position up above? If I did the same for running backs or wide receivers, the disparity looks even greater.

I think you have a better shot gaining an advantage drafting Kittle or McBride in the fourth or fifth, but there is zero chance I am investing such a high pick in Bowers and I feel much more confident in the next tier of tight ends like Evan Engram or David Njoku. Heck, I’d even take the discount on Kelce than I would someone like Jonnu Smith, who broke out last year because of injuries to Dolphins receivers and is now stuck in Pittsburgh sharing snaps with Pat Freiermuth.

You’re going to hear a lot of tight end talk as training camps fire up. People are excited about the top guys and they’re excited about the rookies like Colston Loveland and Tyler Warren. Be ready to sift out the noise and understand where the value is going to be found.

Just like last year, there is no reason to reach so high for the top name. The bottom end of the first tier and the top end of the second tier is where you want to live. You want a tight end who is a functioning part of the offensive scheme and is either second or third on his team in targets. McBride, Kittle, Engram and Njoku stand out the most based on our criteria, with honorable mentions to late-round picks like Mason Taylor and Chig Okonkwo.

We’ll cover more of this as we move further into training camp, but for the time being…

Bender out.

Top Headlines
The Paur Report

Fantasy Life Championship Live Stream (7-9)

Player Notes
Travis Etienne Jul 12 10:20pm CT
Travis Etienne

According to Jeff Howe of The Athletic, Jacksonville Jaguars running back Travis Etienne Jr. needs to have a strong year to be considered a "marquee target" in free agency next offseason. If not, he could become "a back who gets lumped in with the pool of veterans who cycle through one-year deals." The 26-year-old began his career by amassing over 1,000 rushing yards while totaling 17 touchdowns in his first two active seasons. Unfortunately, he's coming off his worst season in the National Football League, accumulating 558 yards and two scores off 150 touches. Tank Bigsby was more productive overall throughout the 2024 campaign. However, it's a new era in Jacksonville, with the organization hiring former Bucs offensive coordinator Liam Coen to serve as the head coach. In addition, the Jags bolstered the running back position by selecting Bhayshul Tuten and LeQuint Allen Jr. in the 2025 NFL Draft. With that in mind, it will be interesting to see how the backfield situation takes shape during training camp. Although Etienne's fantasy stock has never been lower, it appears he at least has a chance to turn things around in 2025. If anything, Etienne should be selected for insurance purposes in case Bigsby goes down with an injury.

From RotoBaller

Wan'Dale Robinson Jul 12 9:30pm CT
Wan'Dale Robinson

New York Giants wide receiver Wan'Dale Robinson has repeatedly expressed his displeasure regarding his role throughout the offseason. The 24-year-old, who played nearly 80% of his snaps in the slot last season, is hoping to get more action on the outside in 2025, potentially opening the door for additional downfield catches. He is coming off his best season with the Giants, amassing career-highs in receptions (93), receiving yards (699) and touchdowns (three). Robinson was also one of the NFL's most targeted receivers inside the red zone. With new quarterbacks under center, specifically, Russell Wilson, Jameis Winston, and rookie Jaxson Dart, it could take time for the offense to get on the same page. At the same time, Malik Nabers is the No. 1 option on the depth chart, leaving little room for anyone else to be involved. However, Robinson may get his wish if Nabers or Darius Slayton get injured at some point during the year. Even then, Robinson isn't expected to be a consistent fantasy producer.

From RotoBaller

Quinshon Judkins Jul 12 8:50pm CT
Quinshon Judkins

Cleveland Browns rookie running back Quinshon Judkins was arrested in Fort Lauderdale for battery and domestic violence on Saturday. According to the Broward County Sheriff's Office, the 21-year-old remains in custody while being charged with touching or striking, battery, and domestic violence. Judkins was selected in the second round with the 36th overall pick by the Browns in the 2025 NFL Draft. He also remains unsigned and now could face discipline under the NFL Personal Conduct Policy as more details come out about his arrest. If Judkins were to miss time this season, Jerome Ford and Dylan Sampson would see an increase in touches and snaps, bumping the draft stock a few spots for both Cleveland backs heading into upcoming fantasy drafts.

From RotoBaller

Terry McLaurin Jul 12 2:00pm CT
Terry McLaurin

Washington Commanders wide receiver Terry McLaurin is entering the final year of his deal and is a candidate to be a holdout or hold-in at training camp this summer. McLaurin has five straight 1,000-yard seasons under his belt and has at least 900 receiving yards in each of his six years in the NFL, but The Athletic's Mike Jones writes that he's unlikely to land a deal that rivals that of Bengals wideout Ja'Marr Chase, who got four years and $161 million. However, it's possible that McLaurin tops the four-year, $115 million deal the Bengals gave receiver Tee Higgins. The 29-year-old had a strong 23.2% target share last year and excelled with impressive rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels, also scoring a career-high 13 touchdowns. McLaurin will see regression in the TD department, but with Daniels looking like an elite QB, McLaurin is now in WR2 territory in fantasy.

From RotoBaller

Roger McCreary Jul 12 1:40pm CT
Roger McCreary

The Athletic's Joe Rexrode believes that giving Tennessee Titans cornerback Roger McCreary a contract extension this summer seems like a smart decision as the former second-rounder in 2022 enters his fourth NFL season. McCreary is by no means an elite defensive back, but he's been versatile and durable for the Titans, missing just four games in his first three years in the league. Tennessee also has plenty of question marks on defense and in their defensive backfield, so it would seem to be a wise move to get the 25-year-old locked in long term. The Auburn alum actually took a step back in 2024, posting a career-low 50 tackles (43 solo), one sack, 12 tackles for loss and only one pass breakup in 15 games (seven starts) in his third season. McCreary spent most of his time in the slot last year and struggled, so the Titans may want to move him back outside, especially if they sign him to an extension.

From RotoBaller

Mike Evans Jul 12 1:30pm CT
Mike Evans

Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver Mike Evans is entering the final year of his two-year, $41 million deal in 2025, and The Athletic's Dan Pompei writes that the team could have a difficult time retaining the future Hall of Famer beyond this season, especially at a similar price to what they just re-signed Chris Godwin at. Despite being close to turning 32 years old, Evans hasn't shown signs of slowing down, posting 1,000 yards receiving in 2024 for the 11th straight season while also scoring 11 touchdowns. Tampa certainly doesn't want to lose one of the greatest players in franchise history who is also highly respected in the locker room, but it remains to be seen how this will play out following the 2025 season after they took wideout Emeka Egbuka in the first round this year. For fantasy purposes, Evans is a high-end WR2.

From RotoBaller

Boye Mafe Jul 12 1:20pm CT
Boye Mafe

Given Seattle Seahawks left tackle Charles Cross' age (24), position and status as the team's best offensive lineman, The Athletic's Michael-Shawn Dugar thinks that signing him to a contract extension before training camp this summer seems like an obvious decision. Cross is one of six extension-eligible players from the team's 2022 draft class, joining outside linebacker Boye Mafe, running back Kenneth Walker III, right tackle Abe Lucas, cornerback Riq Woolen and safety Coby Bryant. Shawn-Dugar adds that Cross should have a salary floor of at least $21 million per year on any new deal he gets. Seattle picked up the 24-year-old's fifth-year option back in April, but it doesn't mean it will prevent them from getting a long-term deal done before the start of the 2025 season. Cross is the unquestioned starting left tackle and will protect new quarterback Sam Darnold's blind side.

From RotoBaller

Xavier Restrepo Jul 12 1:10pm CT
Xavier Restrepo

TennesseeTitans.com's Jim Wyatt highlights rookie wide receiver Xavier Restrepo as a player to watch heading into training camp this summer. Restrepo was added as an undrafted free agent after he was a teammate of quarterback Cam Ward at the University of Miami. The 23-year-old is a fierce competitor who looked comfortable in spring practices. Wyatt writes that Restrepo's 11 catches led all receivers during the five open practices to the media this offseason. If he continues to play that well during camp, the Titans may find it hard to cut him from the active roster going into the regular season. Restrepo had 1,000 yards receiving in his final two seasons with the Hurricanes. He's merely one to watch because of his chemistry with Ward, but he's not an exceptional athlete and is going to face an uphill battle for a roster spot.

From RotoBaller

Calvin Ridley Jul 12 1:00pm CT
Calvin Ridley

TennesseeTitans.com's Jim Wyatt writes that Tennessee Titans wide receiver Calvin Ridley appears to be re-energized in his second season with the team with the addition of rookie first-round quarterback Cam Ward. Ridley has taken the first overall pick under his wing this offseason, and they have both formed a strong bond both on the field and off. For Tennessee's offense to take a step forward in 2025, the Titans will need the chemistry between Ward and Ridley to pay off after Ridley went for 64 catches, 1,017 yards and four touchdowns in his first year with the team in 2024. The 30-year-old is the clear WR1 and should continue to have a high target share, but his fantasy value will be directly impacted by how quickly Ward can adapt to the speed in the NFL. Ridley is ranked at RotoBaller a the No. 32 fantasy wideout.

From RotoBaller

Mark Andrews Jul 12 12:40pm CT
Mark Andrews

There was some speculation this offseason that the Baltimore Ravens might be moving on from tight end Mark Andrews after his disappointing outing in the playoff loss to the Buffalo Bills in the divisional round. However, Andrews is still on the roster and is in the TE mix for the Ravens alongside Isaiah Likely and Charlie Kolar with training camp right around the corner. All three of Andrews, Likely and Kolar are scheduled to be free agents in 2026, so they should all be highly motivated, writes The Athletic's Jeff Zrebiec. Andrews should continue to have a key role in the offense, but the addition of veteran receiver DeAndre Hopkins could mean that targets will be tougher to come by in an offense that remains run-first. The 29-year-old looked done early in 2024 before scoring 11 TDs in a 12-game span. Likely is a problem for sure, but as long as Andrews stays healthy, he should be in play as a midrange TE1 in fantasy.

From RotoBaller

Jaylen Waddle Jul 12 12:20pm CT
Jaylen Waddle

Miami Dolphins wide receiver Jaylen Waddle appears to be plenty motivated in 2025 after the offense took a step back in 2024, with Waddle falling short of a fourth straight 1,000-yard season. Waddle finished with 744 yards and two touchdowns on 58 catches, all career-lows. "After watching the film, definitely a lot of hand eye (coordination) -- I feel like I'm trying to move without the ball too much," he said. "And just the simple things, just timing, getting smoother in and out of my routes. Pretty much that," Waddle said. The 26-year-old has also been improving his chemistry with quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. A bounce-back campaign in 2025 is certainly possible for the speedy Waddle, but unfortunately his fantasy value is tied to the injury-prone Tagovailoa and an offense that was a shell of its former self last year. RotoBaller has Waddle ranked as the WR28.

From RotoBaller

Tre Harris Jul 12 12:10pm CT
Tre Harris

The Los Angeles Chargers rookies are reporting to training camp on Saturday, but the Bolts and second-round wide receiver Tre Harris still haven't agreed to a deal, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter. There is still time for the two sides to get something done before official practices begin, but Harris is facing the possibility of missing some key development time heading into his first NFL season. The 23-year-old looked impressive during OTAs and minicamp earlier this offseason while building chemistry with quarterback Justin Herbert. The Chargers are hoping that Harris can be Herbert's go-to deep threat in 2025 to open up more space for WR1 Ladd McConkey underneath. Harris will be fighting for targets with Mike Williams and Quentin Johnston. Despite being in a run-first offense, Harris is in a good situation for immediate playing time in 2025.

From RotoBaller

Sauce Gardner Jul 11 7:00pm CT
Sauce Gardner

The Athletic's Zack Rosenblatt writes that New York Jets cornerback Sauce Gardner wants to be the highest-paid cornerback in the league. Additionally, the Jets need to figure out when to extend wide receiver Garrett Wilson, who is seeking in the range of $25-30 million per year. Gardner has stated that he would like to retire as a Jet, but the team will probably need to move fast to avoid prices going up. The 24-year-old defensive back is entering the final year of his rookie contract in 2025 and has already become one of the top shutdown corners in the NFL. The former fourth overall pick in 2022 out of Cincinnati is a two-time Pro Bowler and also won Defensive Rookie of the Year in 2022. Gardner finished with 49 tackles (36 solo), his first career sack, an interception and nine pass breakups in 15 starts in 2024.

From RotoBaller

Rhamondre Stevenson Jul 11 6:40pm CT
Rhamondre Stevenson

The New England Patriots gave running back Rhamondre Stevenson a four-year, $36 million extension last summer, which kicks in for the 2025 season. The Athletic's Chad Graff writes that the extension for Stevenson already looks like a bad move after he had 207 carries for 807 yards (career-low 3.9 yards per carry) last year, although he did score a career-high seven rushing touchdowns. On top of it, the Pats selected rookie TreVeyon Henderson in the second round this year, so New England now have an out to move on from Stevenson if he struggles again in 2025. The biggest drawback to the 27-year-old last year were his seven fumbles. He has nice size and abilities in the passing game, but he won't be guaranteed much under the new coaching staff and will face plenty of competition from Henderson. RotoBaller has Stevenson ranked as the RB35 in fantasy.

From RotoBaller

Josh Metellus Jul 11 6:30pm CT
Josh Metellus

The Athletic's Alec Lewis writes that safety Josh Metellus and the Minnesota Vikings have mutual interest in hammering out a contract extension, but it remains to be seen if they can find common ground on a deal. Metellus has been an integral contributor for defensive coordinator Brian Flores for his ability to play as a linebacker and in the slot, so the Vikings would surely like to keep his versatility around as he heads into the final year of his current contract. The 27-year-old defensive back is also a captain and contributes on special teams. The former sixth-rounder has had 100-plus combined tackles the last two years in Minnesota, and while his versatility could complicate extension talks, it also allows him to play up in the box more often than most safeties and rack up tackles for fantasy managers in IDP leagues.

From RotoBaller

Tua Tagovailoa Jul 11 6:20pm CT
Tua Tagovailoa

While it's probably unlikely, The Athletic's Jim Ayello points out there's a chance that the 2025 season is quarterback Tua Tagovailoa's last year with the Miami Dolphins. The Dolphins aren't in a pretty salary-cap situation moving forward, so if they have a five- or six-win season this year, it's possible that ownership decides it's time for a hard reset. It's quite possible that Miami's decision-makers going into next year think that Tua's concussion history and limitations as a pocket passer don't make him an ideal franchise signal-caller. The former first-rounder's value, both in fantasy and real life, all depend on his health and what he can produce in 2025. If the Dolphins were to cut Tagovailoa after this year, it would come with a hefty $79 million dead-cap hit. There's bounce-back potential for Tua and the Dolphins offense, but fantasy managers shouldn't be taking him as anything more than a QB2 with upside.

From RotoBaller

Ben Johnson Jul 11 2:20pm CT
Ben Johnson

The Chicago Bears and general manager Ryan Poles have reached an agreement on a contract extension, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter. The new deal will keep Poles in Chicago through the 2029 season, and his contract length now matches that of first-year head coach Ben Johnson. Poles has a mixed track record in his time at the helm for Chicago. The team has struggled on the field, going 15-36 through his first three seasons in charge. However, Poles positioned the team to acquire quarterback Caleb Williams by pulling off a trade with the Carolina Panthers that netted the Bears the number one overall pick in the 2024 draft. Poles' future with the team will be closely linked to the success of both Williams and his second head coaching hire in Johnson, but he's locked in some additional security with this extension.

From RotoBaller

MarShawn Lloyd Jul 11 2:10pm CT
MarShawn Lloyd

Green Bay Packers running back MarShawn Lloyd is "in a much better spot" and the team has "a lot of high expectations for him," Green Bay running backs coach Ben Sirmans told Matt Schneidman of The Athletic. Drafted in the third round in 2024, Lloyd had a lost year as a rookie. He appeared in just one game for Green Bay last season, totaling six carries for 15 yards. Lloyd suffered myriad injuries to his hip, ankle, hamstring, and appendicitis. In the same article, Schneidman notes that Lloyd is "essentially a lock" to make the Packers' 53-man roster, but may not start as the number two running back on the depth chart behind Josh Jacobs. He's competing with Emanuel Wilson and Chris Brooks for the role, both of whom flashed at different points in 2024. Lloyd has a ways to go before he's relevant for fantasy managers, but his progress in camp should be monitored by those looking for a Jacobs handcuff.

From RotoBaller

Dustin Hopkins Jul 11 2:00pm CT
Dustin Hopkins

Cleveland Browns kicker Dustin Hopkins will "get every opportunity" to rebound from a down year in 2024, according to Chris Easterling of the Akron Beacon Journal. Hopkins had an excellent year in 2023 when he made 33 of his 36 kicks, including all eight attempts from beyond 50 yards. He was significantly worse in 2024, going just 18-27 overall and four-for-eight from 50+ yards out. Easterling notes that Hopkins' primary competition in Browns' camp is Andre Szmyt, who has yet to record a kick in an NFL game. Hopkins is just starting a three-year contract extension that he signed in July 2024, so the team is counting on him regaining his prior form. RotoBaller currently has Hopkins ranked as kicker #27 for fantasy.

From RotoBaller

Jalen Nailor Jul 11 1:40pm CT
Jalen Nailor

Minnesota Vikings wide receiver Jalen Nailor "will be the team's No. 3 receiver," according to Alec Lewis of The Athletic. Lewis also notes that Nailor showed up to organized team activities in the "best shape of his life." Nailor played 17 games for Minnesota last season, recording 28 receptions for 414 yards and six touchdowns. His most productive stretch of the season might have been from Week 2-3, where he tallied a combined six catches for 85 yards and two scores. That's noteworthy because those are the two games that fellow Minnesota wideout Jordan Addison missed in 2024. Addison could be facing an early-season suspension due to a DUI citation he received last summer. If that happens, Nailor could be a sneaky end-of-roster add for fantasy managers.

From RotoBaller